April 26, 2009

An Anthropologist among the Marxists

I just completed this  collection of essays by Ramachandra Guha. The essays are biographical sketches of patriots, intellectuals or just interesting characters who have influenced India in this century. They are the lesser knowns or unknowns that Guha thought should also be acknowledged by history. 

The book initially profiles  people like C V Subba Rao- essentially Marxists or naxal sympathisers. The middle part of the book is 'the use and abuse of Gandhi', about people who are linked with Gandhi somehow or the other. Mira Behn, Herbert Fischer (a German who came from WW-2 Germany and worked close to Gandhi for several years), J C Kumarappa (the green Gandhian), K Swaminathan (who spent his entire career putting together the Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, a comprehensive collection of his writing, letters, speeches etc, which Guha claims that every book written hence on Gandhi heavily draws from. Guha is incidentally closely related to Swaminathan) are the subjects of essays.  Essays about Gandhi's relationship with Bengal, with Ambedkar were also good.

Another good one was about M. Krishnan, who seems to be an eminent naturalist.  

Many of the essays are readable because of the subject matter: the people being sketched have led unique lives. But Guha also has a very personal and almost theatrical style of writing, which makes history lively- I think school history would have been more captivating if it were more in this style than its current dry, date and fact driven style.

For instance, he has met or talked to most of the people covered in the book, which is one of the reasons he is able to write with passion about them. 

All in all, a good book to read.

5 comments:

SLN said...

When and where do you find the time to put in this much of reading?

Krupa Singampalli said...

Why don't you create pages on google groups and summarize your readings, so us poor souls can glean some pearls of wisdom in a condensed format.

ssk said...

hats off to yr thrist

Krupakar said...

Anatomy of a bus journey:

Total time take for travel to and from office by bus: 1 Hr 45 M

Time to read The Hindu: 35 M
Time to read book: 1 Hr 10 M

So I get 6 Hours of book reading time per week. Since the option to not reading is to stare into mindless traffic, I get to read 'serious' books that I wouldn't read otherwise.

Krupa Singampalli said...

You can read in a moving vehicle? I envy you so. I get terrible motion sickness if I read in a bus or car.