May 5, 2010

The Big Switch

I recently read a book called "The Big Switch" by Nicholas Carr. It makes a good argument that the computing power will be commoditized in the future, much like electricity, with the recent trends into Cloud computing and hosting services by Amazon Electric Cloud and Microsoft Azure etc....

He discusses how earlier factories used to have their own electric generators on site, and how the trend ended up with power companies supplying power from a grid. I first heard of the term grid computing about 6 years ago. It morphed into the "cloud" now. But it is a philosophy I can get behind on. If you are a company, why would you want to maintain expensive server farms? Why not buy the computing power? This book, and a few other articles argue that IT is no longer a competitive advantage for companies, just like buildings and people, it is a necessary part of the business operations and you are better off leaving it to companies that do it best.

Any thoughts by the engineers in the family??????? And there are quite a few around..... :-)

5 comments:

Krupakar said...

Why not indeed? But it seems be an exaggeration to say that cloud computing would be the default and IT would be commodotized.

The analogy of comparing it to utilities like electricity and water supply is not perfect. Electricity is a simple product with no variants-in fact, the effort is to standardize (voltage rating for eg). The reason for centralizing is also to control consumption, since electricity is a scare resource and considered a public good.

In the case of IT, the needs vary widely per circumstance- and the needs are constantly changing too. So while there would be situations where cloud computing would give savings of scale (Amazon etc), in many cases, companies may trade off scale savings for flexibility.

So folks who think cloud computing is the next big thing are perhaps building castles in the air! ;-)

Krupa Singampalli said...

That is exactly the point though. Computing power is generic. You need so many CPUs, so much data storage, so much memory etc... , just like you need so many KW at such and such frequency.

You can play games, run office software, read books, using the same generic "computing power". So, why do you need to manage and maintain your own instances of CPUs, Database servers, storage servers etcc. Why not buy as you need just like electricity??

In fact, cloud computing has reduced infrastructure costs so dramatically, many startups are able to get to market at much less expense.

SLN said...

WHAT ! ME TRUST ANOTHER FELLOW???
The internet was a truly democratic institution with little people, big people, all contributing. Sort of like people playing the age of empires.
--------------------------
lot of exchanges of info, songs, free software movement etc.
Mails, chats, IRCs and YOUTUBE.
Linux happened and the apple-Ms wars were creating waves.
Some people even dreamed of using the unused energy and time left on the connected computers--sort of collaborative projects like SETI. I was also invited thru several sites but it was too costly an idea for me you see!
And some people did and do use the spare power for DoS and DDoS attacks thru Trojans.
----------------------------------

Now people start butting in--Cloud computing, online storage, on line office-windows live. Go up in the air etc.
--------------------------------
1.But what of putting all your secrets in somebody's hands?

2.If somebody's server farm is hacked, will all my trade plans go into somebody Else's hands?

3.If by chance, the undersea cable has snapped or the satellites are on the blink due to solar flares- how can I access my data?
AH! have a backup. Then why do I need THAT frontdown?

4. What if Google shuts down on India like it did on China? Do I migrate all my data?
5.And like moving places on a transferable job, do I keep rolling my data all over the internet--like switching the cell phone service providers when there is a new attractive offer?
6. You may save inventory but will the service come cheap? and if you consider the security,Industrial espionage etc. are the risks worth it?
7. Of course online collaboration, collation etc. may be easier and cheaper but won't a VPN do an efficient job?

8. Huh! so I say a lot.
Pure envy that I could not start on such an idea and reach the pot of gold.:)
-----------------------------------------
No way! my fears are real. Assuage them before I put all my business online.
Trusting my family jewels to another, however skilled he might be.
The Bultibillionaire SLN.
Entrepreneur par excellence.
Kavali.India

Srini said...

I was reading this blog at work and my colleague looked over and said nice thoughts.
When I told him SLN was a doctor by profession, he was shocked and as customary..called me "the black spot" of the family for not participating in such a rich discussion

Gowri said...

Yes .Commoditize and commercialise IT.Your office is bugged ,yr home is bugged ,yr finances are bugged.Result--viruses everywhere corrupting.Pray to GOD"let not the mind and heart be bugged".Since there is something called CONSCIENCE still left, man is able to survive.If that can be accessed and corrupted ,it is doom for mankind.