With Normal Borlaug fresh in our minds, I thought to spend a little time bringing the eternal telephone discussions between me and nanna about genetic modifications to the blog.
Norman Borlaug was given Padma Vibhushan and Noble Peace Prize for bringing the genetically modified high yield wheat to developing nations like India, Pakistan and Mexico, contributing a large part to India's self sustenance in food. But critics argue that such grains alter the balance of nature and reap large profits to companies like Monsanto.
People argue it is a slippery slope from BT corn and BT cotton to BT kids or Designer kids. But couldn't we make the same argument on all the diseases being cured.
I believe in scientific progress and believe that science benefitted the human kind more than it harmed.
Any thoughts?
7 comments:
Welcome back! It's been a while. On GM, it is a crazy idea. I am with greenpeace on this one. If solving problem requires creation of other problems, it is not really a solution- it is just a crude fix, bad design etc. The means are always always as important as the ends. Sanjay Gandhi might have had genuine intention of curtailing the population explosion in India, but what a bad solution. And if after all the mad cows diseases and other problems, if people still don't get that they need to treat nature with some respect, they are just asking for trouble. See 'I am Legend' ..it is a scarily viable situation.
But you wouldn't necessarily know upfront whether it is a good idea or bad. If you only let nature take its course, infant mortality rates would not go so low or longevity grow that much. Would you argue that we should let people die who can't fight off diseases because nature intended the weak to perish? Is hunger and famine a better alternate to GM food?
It doesn't workout like that Krupa! not the q. of GM food vs hunger and famine. If you take THAT argument further and argue that hunger is cured by this--then pl. go back to Darwin--in periods of affluence, there will be explosion of population leading to overcrowding and (finally lemming like death)competition for food. Only populations with needed adjustments survive and the rest DO perish. So finally, in a roundabout way, you have achieved the original result.
The high yields were associated with decreased resistance and hence --more powerful pesticides, more pesticides etc ( and those pesticides helped several cotton farmers to reach their end--gruesome humour). All this has caused environmental pollution, chronic poisoning etc. Oh! the debate can rage endlessly.
Bottom line--yes GM is needed, but ever so slowly, like nature does in her lab. (Festina Lente)
Newer antibiotic to kill a superbug, you get a superduper bug in a short while.
BORLAUG was a great guy. The green revolutiono owes a lot to him and none of his products were associated with BIG problems like with Monsanto products aka BT what have you.
And the killer genes being incorporated into the seeds donot permit the farmer to use his own home grown seed. He has to go back every year for seed to the company. There you see the ugly face of business.
"Newer antibiotic to kill a superbug, you get a superduper bug in a short while." - My point exactly. Nature is constantly evolving and science is man's way of being the fittest and surviving. Man constructed houses to shelter from the weather and discovered antibiotics to shelter from disease and BT foods to shelter from famine.
today i read a news "naarumallu poyatam uneconomical.lots of wastage of seedlings-naaru.so in a short while multi nationals will step in and set up nurseries .finally the farmer can not have his seed ,not have his crop and not have his food.buys seed from monsanto sells the crop to the pettubadidaru who financed and buy his food from reliance fresh store.bangaru theegalu pandinchina rytu ki pattedu podi methukulu levu. 2.man with his greed and avariceness is leading to the extinction of planet earth .but it is not true,planet will be there MAN will be extinct.famine and hunger are not because of low yield but because of the hoarders .the predictable nature of nature is its unpredictably predictable regularity with which it regulates nature and consequently the life on earth.bhoomi manishi(homo sapiens )swantha jagir kaadu.learn to live in harmony with nature.ee planet earth meeda neeku entha adhikaaram hakku unnayo cheema ku virus ku bacteria ku anthe vunnayi d..dont try to eradicate and modify them and bring doom over yr head
why can't we eradicate mosquitoes and so malaria is a common question posed by many.Mosquitoes came in quite early on earth and man only recently. Maybe mosquitoes were running out of food and God(nature) made man to meet the needs of mosquitoes?:)
Or maybe the time of mosquitoes is nearing an end? How do you know all things man is doing are not what nature intended man to do? Why can't they be part of the evolution?
Post a Comment