September 12, 2013

Are Americans exceptional?

A op-ed by Putin in NY Times has America up in arms, especially the last paragraph. Comments?

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/12/opinion/putin-plea-for-caution-from-russia-on-syria.html?_r=0

2 comments:

Krupakar said...

I had also read this in the AM. The debate around 'Are Americans exceptional?' is pretty inane, I guess. 'Exceptionalism' is not a description of a people, but a policy approach of the US government. It is not that the American people are exceptional, but that the US government consistently pursues a foreign policy that ensures exceptional and differential comforts to its citizens. It supposedly started with the subduing of Geronimo, and was the driving force behind the CIA's actions in the mid part of the century.

So if Obama used this word to talk of how the US defends democracy around the world, it is just an articulate politician doing a spiel. But it is laughable that Putin gets on a high horse and talks about UN laws etc. He can be either a savant or a bare-chested horse rider who stages stunts and runs a corrupt government - he had made that choice a long time ago.

I think the whole debate is just the excitement that the average man feels when a celebrity deigns to notice him. Through social media, people like Putin can indulge their egos by talking wisely down to distant lands, and the hoi-polloi can feel thrilled that he is talking directly to them. So this is not a debate, it is entertainment.

SLN said...

Krups and Krups! Read animal farm.
American policy----Call a dog mad before you shoot it and might is right.
Like we saw in the comments section of my last post, there are problems of discrimination galore at home but charity does not begin at home.Only Petro dollars and disguised crusades work. All the presidents supported by USA were dictators--in South America and elsewhere, but they were supported because they were American supporters. They were all thrown out and US lost wars in Vietnam and Korea.
Of course, we know about Russia. They have moderated a bit and in the present world Scenario, they are milder and have more leaning towards peaceful solutions than others. But Serbia and Afghanistan are too recent to be forgotten.
Ultimately USA , UK, France and Australia want to be the saviors of the world peace and since there is none to tackle their aggression, we better learn to live with it. Russia of course will do a bit of sabre rattling and then keep quiet as it did in Iraq-II.
Putin's sayings--Brave posturings to catch the eye of the world and sow a few seeds of dissension among American public if he can.