May 18, 2009

Prarapa Impact

I disagree. You can see that they got 15% of the vote, which made a huge impact in how much TDP was able to gain. The anti-incumbent vote split quite a bit. If there was no PRP, TDP might have gained more seats, unseating congress in AP.

2 comments:

SLN said...

same argument everywhere. many facets to this coin.
who said that it is all anti incumbent vote?
how many of them would have gone to congress?
Last time around, when chiranjeevi asked his fans to vote for Aswini Dutt, many got angry and said" let him form his own party and we will vote for him. Otherwise we choose our way, for there are several local factors-we are congress supporters and will vote congress. He should not give a direction like that." They even burnt his effigy in chittoor. He later retracted the statement and said that he was sorry.
Many of his voters are the kids voting first time and we donot know whom they might have voted for if not for PRP. My sneaking suspicion is that many of these would have voted congress as they received fee reimbursements from the govt. (last yr all SC ST BC candidates got their fees reimbursed in all courses including B.Tech and MBBS. Nearly 70% of the students benefited--even Krishna's son got it.) The 15% might have gone as 5% congress 5% TDP 5% not voted!!!
Antiincumbency vote is always split as there will be only one incumbent and Myriad antis. If you have only 2 parties, then you might think like that.
They might have voted Loksatta or BJP or independents or communists. So, tell me how you can say that TDP suffered losses due to PRP?
They were a hodgepodge kootami who didnot transfer there own votes in favor of each other.
There was a lot of cross voting too. Even where TDP won the assembly seat,the MP candidate polled fewer votes--the TDP supporters themselves were voting for congress MPs.
And finally the verdict is in and any amount of carping or justification by the oposition is not going to change it.
Even YSR has been warned. His strength also diminished by abt 25 seats.May be they were among the 18 won by PRP.

Krupakar said...

I think what is more interesting is what he will do, having reached this Trishanku Swargam stage. Having imagined that he will sweep to power by dint of his stardom, he finds himself instead relegated to the lowly back benches. Does he really have the stamina to continue with politics, knowing that the prospects of his ruling the state are pretty bleak even in the distant future?